It’s been nearly 20 years since John Tucker Must Die showed Us the consequences of messing with the love lives of high school girls.

The 2006 revenge rom-com follows Heather (Ashanti), Beth (Sophia Bush) and Carrie (Arielle Kebbel) as they attempt to bring down John (Jesse Metcalfe) after learning he was dating all three of them at once. To do so, they recruit new girl Kate (Brittany Snow) to get him to fall in love with her, then break his heart. That way, he would know how it feels.

The flick — which features a stellar supporting cast including Jenny McCarthy, Taylor Kitsch and Penn Badgley — became a fan favorite from the moment it hit theaters. Metcalfe, who has gone on to land dozens of roles, still gets fans coming up to him nearly 15 years later.

“I didn’t think really much of the movie when I was shooting it, and the fact that it’s kind of become a little bit of a teen comedy cult classic is awesome,” he exclusively told Us Weekly in October 2020. “It’s been passed down, maybe from, like, older brothers and sisters to their younger siblings. I think it’s super cool. People still think it’s funny! It is funny. I’m flattered.”

Scroll through the gallery below to see where the cast is today: